I've been seeing a lot about Truphone lately, but have been a bit reluctant to comment. Reluctant because the folks at Truphone are friends. But, I feel compelled to be honest, and my friends know me for speaking my mind.
First some links to the current conversation:
Truphone Looks Forward to an Exciting 2009
By Greg Galitzine, Group Editorial Director
Truphone (News - Alert) is a free application that's designed to allow users to inexpensively make international mobile calls from their own phone over the Internet. Earlier this year the company announced a native VoIP client for the iPhone developed with Apple's (News - Alert) own SDK, available via the online iPhone App Store. The solution routes calls over WiFi, so if the user finds themselves near a hotspot and needs to make a call, they can simply call up the Truphone application on theiriPhone ( News - Alert) and place the call.
[Read Greg's Full Post]
Greg's very up on Truphone, and his interview questions with Matt Rowntree reflect that. There wasn't anything but fat pitches in there - not one hard question.
Truphone is a finalist in the
2008 Crunchies.
And they've gotten lots of praise in the traditional press.
Check the bottom of their home page.
So why am I not jumping up and down? I've been a Truphone user for a while - a long while, and yet I rarely find it useful or usable. I don't think I'm the anomaly either.
I used Truphone a bit on my N95, but I move my AT&T SIM from phone to phone. I've been haggling with the Truphone gang for ages to put up a Blackberry version. Recently they did. And if it worked, I might say good things about it. But it seized control of the BB without noting it would in the nonexistent documentation (FAQs and docs are very thin). Then, naturally, it wouldn't work. I could close my account and open a new one. It's tied to the SIM so moving it is impossible without support involvement that is interesting when we're across the pond.
So why is a service that's tied to my phone number on my SIM set up in a way that I can't actually use it when I move the SIM without closing the account, losing the credit, dealing with admin overhead of readding the credit. And if I move my SIM daily(and I do)? Ahh, so Truphone doesn't fit. And to my testing, the Blackberry version may work. I've heard a couple of reports that it does. Non glowing from people I know. I've seen a lot of "my friends at Truphone tell me..."
Then we got the iPod Touch release. Sheryl installed it and we managed to make one call successfully. One success to Gizmo SIP URL only, and that after two hours of putzing with it. So I installed it on my iPod, and my account can't work with it. I need yet another Truphone account apparently. Excuse me?
So in the interest of fairness, I went digging for info and found
Sorry to our iPhone App users. We don't have an iPhone, but to be honest, two for two failure doesn't engender the kind of assurance that would send me rushing to install Truphone on one anyway at this point.
I want to own up to something. The gang at Truphone are friends. Yes, I could spend time on the phone working with them, helping them see the problems and rectify them. As a good friend, I should do that. As a consumer, if I have to do that, where does that leave all the people who are loading this stuff and having problems who don't actually have the Truphone gang as friends?
I'm disappointed in what I've seen from Truphone. And I'm disappointed to see a product at this level up for a Crunchie. It speaks ill of our industry, devalues awards and recognition, and doesn't serve the public well.
I'm very disappointed.
Technorati Tags:
Truphone,
Blackberry,
iPod Touch,
iPhone,
Crunchies